Phillies Only Add Bryan Rincon to 40 Man Roster With Rule 5 Draft Uncertain

Today was the deadline to add players to 40 man roster to protect them from the major league Rule 5 draft. The twist this year is that there may not be a major league Rule 5 draft at all. With the impending lockout, the draft would be put on hold, and the last time that happened it didn’t occur at all. Teams are still protecting based on their own risk assessments of a draft happening. A minor league Rule 5 draft will still happen and the Phillies are certain to protect anyone of note from that draft.

All that being said, the Phillies only added SS Bryan Rincon to their 40 man roster. Rincon is a top 5 prospect in the system and has a very plausible way to helping the Phillies or another club in 2027.

There is some surprises beyond that with IF Aroon Escobar and LHP Mavis Graves being the notable players left unprotected. First the Phillies are making a high probability bet that there will once again not be a major league Rule 5 draft after the lockout. By not protecting either player they don’t start an options clock and keep their 40 man roster cleaner heading into the rest of the offseason. They also can continue to work with both players during the lockout as they will be on minor league contracts and not major league ones (Rincon will be locked out).

If there is a draft, it is unlikely that Escobar would be selected. He does not have the defensive positioning to fit well on a bench, and coming off a disappointing year in AA he isn’t going to contribute at the plate either. In the past a team might have considered taking him and stashing him, but that type of move has not occurred in recent years.

Graves is probably more at risk as a LH reliever who can get lefties out. There is dearth of LHPs and a rising amount of LHBs and that makes any southpaw valuable. Graves also has great feel for spin and a good changeup that does make him not useless against RHBs. However, he is still a pitcher who has only been in the bullpen for a few months and has a minus fastball. Given an offseason to work with him, he might be more attractive to a major league team, but even if there is a draft he would go straight from AA to the major leagues without any real dev time or runway. He could still be selected, but when coupled with the odds of there being a draft, you can see why the Phillies did what they did.

A couple other players of note. SS Juan Villavicencio is a top 20 prospect in the org, but his distance from the majors makes him unlikely to be selected in a normal year. RHP Wen-Hui Pan has been a good story, but his fastball has been more mid 90s than upper 90s and has a pretty poor shape. In the long term he could harness his splitter into being a useful major league reliever, but he isn’t there yet. He lacks the high end upside and nearside certainty to be a selection.

Leave a Comment