A Critical Look at the Phillies Organization and Minor League Baseball
Top prospect lists are not really an accurate representation of the young talent in a farm system. Aaron Nola will be 24 on opening day or the same age as Jorge Alfaro. Rhys Hoskins was one of the biggest breakouts for the Phillies in 2017 and has under 2 months of major league service time. … Read more
The format of going 10 by 10 works from a publishing and writing schedule, but it leaves some nuance out. One of those pieces of nuance is the tiers of prospects that emerge. These tiers I think do a better job of showing similarly valued players. Tier 1: J.P. Crawford (1) Sixto Sanchez (2) Scott … Read more
In some ways the the top 10 of the prospect list is anticlimactic. The players on the list are of a surprise to no one and most of these players have been well reported on. That feeling lasts until you start to write about players like Jhailyn Ortiz, Scott Kingery, Sixto Sanchez, and others. It … Read more
There was a clear divide from 30 to 31 and while there isn’t a complete divide from 20 to 21, the divide from 11 to 20 is clear. The top prospects on this list should be top 10 prospects in this system, there was just 12 names and 10 spots. There might not be a … Read more
A list of 30 prospects in a system has become standard, and while this list goes to 50, 30 is where it really hits its stride. These 10 players aren’t perfect prospects, but they are players with a chance to make real major league impact. That ranges from back end starting pitchers who could be … Read more
Development is not linear. It is easy to look at many in this group of prospects and see disappointment. It is true that some of the prospects in this range dropped off cover the 2017 season, others jumped forward as they started into their pro careers, and two in Victor Arano and Ben Lively made … Read more
It is list time of year again, or in reality we are reaching the end of the list season. I apologize for the late start to this and the lack of content in general. Before getting into the numbers and names, my hope is that I provide you the resources to create your own order … Read more
It is ranking season. Baseball America kicked things off with their Phillies Top 10 today. Here is Ben Badler’s List: J.P. Crawford Sixto Sanchez Scott Kingery Adonis Medina Adam Haseley JoJo Romero Jhailyn Ortiz Jorge Alfaro Mickey Moniak Franklyn Kilome Before talking order, here is Ben’s midseason list (with the Top 100 rank from BA … Read more
Each year, Mike Drago of the Reading Eagle reaches out to local and national bloggers, broadcasters, and writers for their Phillies’ prospect rankings. Those rankings are then aggregated into a combined Top 30. This was the second year that Mike reached out to me to participate and it gave me a good opportunity to make … Read more
Prospect lists in general are arbitrary things, midseason lists are doubly so. Each evaluator talks to different people, and each person has their own set of biases and values. When it comes to midseason lists, we add in a time factor as games are still going on. I am writing this list nearly a month … Read more